ARBERIAONLINE

I believe most of the IE languages were initiated in a religious "soil" and they are just cultivated languages. Albanian and the paleo-Germanic are the only exception to this rule:

Tema po duket interesante, ama do te ishte mire ta elaborosh me gjate se pse beson se disa nga gjuhe jane kultivuar nga fete, apo kane origjine fetare dhe tjerat jane gjuhe etnike apo gjuhe te folura qe ne gjeneze.

Rina wrote: ↑Sun Sep 16, 2018 3:06 pm Tema po duket interesante, ama do te ishte mire ta elaborosh me gjate se pse beson se disa nga gjuhe jane kultivuar nga fete, apo kane origjine fetare dhe tjerat jane gjuhe etnike apo gjuhe te folura qe ne gjeneze.

Kete bindje e kam, pas studimit me vemendje te historise se Europes. 'Nacionalizimi i historise', ne fakt eshte nje koncept i gabuar, sepse ai i jep kredit te pamerituar, disa kombeve, qe nuk kane histori etnike, ose te pakten i barazon ata ne te njejten status, me ata qe e kane, sic jane shqiptaret. Per kete arsye, une i ndava "racat", ne 'raca' te dala prej gjirit te cultures(fese) dhe raca qe kane demonstruar nje karrakter tribal. Mendoj se diagram e mesiperme, eshte me afer realitetit, krahasuar me ato te deritashmet.

Zeus10 wrote: ↑Mon Sep 10, 2018 10:24 pm I believe most of the IE languages were initiated in a religious "soil" and they are just cultivated languages. Albanian and the paleo-Germanic are the only exception to this rule:
IE language tree.jpg

So if I'm reading this right, Albanian seems to derive from Arberor+Eastern Church?

IllyrianLegend wrote: ↑Wed Oct 03, 2018 12:31 pm

Zeus10 wrote: ↑Mon Sep 10, 2018 10:24 pm I believe most of the IE languages were initiated in a religious "soil" and they are just cultivated languages. Albanian and the paleo-Germanic are the only exception to this rule:
IE language tree.jpg

So if I'm reading this right, Albanian seems to derive from Arberor+Eastern Church?

No, the origin is definitely Arberor, but the lexicon is enriched by borrowing terms from Latin and Byzantine Church language, terms which in most part were originally Arberor.

Zeus10 wrote: ↑Mon Sep 10, 2018 10:24 pm I believe most of the IE languages were initiated in a religious "soil" and they are just cultivated languages. Albanian and the paleo-Germanic are the only exception to this rule:
IE language tree.jpg

You can link this idea with words that in antiquity were used for ''religious'' and cultural beliefs and are still preserved today. For example i see that languages that you have classified as ethnic soil are using week-day words of pagan origin. While the religious soil languages show influence from Christianity and all words are dedicated there.
For reference, in ancient Greece the week days were called just like the Albanian ones today.