Page 1 of 2

Origjina e shqiptareve.

Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2012 5:20 pm
by Zeus10
Le te diskutojme per origjinen e popullit shqiptar. A jemi te mocem ne kete vend? A jemi te perjetshem aty, ne kuptimin relativ te fjales? A mos jemi nje shtresim mbi autoktonet? A kemi larguar dike prej andej? Apo jemi po aq te vjeter, sa gjithe kombet rreth nesh?
Opinioni im:
Ne jemi popullsite e ardhura nga PERENDIMI, ndoshta avangarda e atyre qe ne histori njihen si romake. Kjo avangarde perfshin popullsite qe dikur banonin rreth sot Portugalise, Spanjes edhe Frances qe njihen ne histori me emrin Albane dhe e vendosen qendren e tyre, atje ku sot eshte Roma. Albanet qe u vendosen ne Shqiperi zhvendosen ose treten popullsine vendase, qe ka qene semitike, ose dhe me e larget, duke u bere kombi dominant ne keto troje, per te pakten 1000 vjete. Gjuha e folur nga keta Albane u zevendesua ne Perendim nga gjuhet Romance te Perendimit, kurse ne Lindje nga gjuha Romake e Lindjes(greqishtja) dhe gjuhet e Ortodoksise Sllavike. Gjuha vernakulare e albaneve, ka filluar ne Portugali dhe ka mbaruar ne Lindjen e Mesme.

Re: Origjina e shqiptareve.

Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2012 5:49 pm
by Patush
Toka nuk a e kerkujte por i forti sundon mbi te!
Kam fillu me kriju mendimin se kena mete ne te kalumen ne vend qe te perqendrohemi ne te ardhmen?

Te ardhure nga Portugalia? This has been one of those wtf moments that create shock in Patush's brain and contribute to the growth of the tumor inside of it!

Zeus pse hedh komente te tilla provokuese te pa ndjekura me shpjegimin qe ke por qe e mban peng? :mrgreen:

Shihe cka din Patushi per vedin e tije: Nga im ate vij nga Mirdita, te ram ne rrethin e Shkodres aty afer 200-300 vjet, prej nga nana rranjet i kam nga Shkreli!

Re: Origjina e shqiptareve.

Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2012 6:04 pm
by Zeus10
-haha- Patush, kur them qe fillimet e races se Albaneve jane ne Perendim dhe pikerisht atje ku sot eshte Portugalia, kjo nuk do te thote qe ne jemi portugeze, por ne nje moment te verifikueshem te historise, kemi levizur nga Perendimi ne Lindje, aq larg sac eshte Lindja e Mesme dhe ka pasur dhe vale te races tone nga drejtimi i kundert, sidomos nga presioni i popujve aziatike.

Re: Origjina e shqiptareve.

Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2012 7:22 pm
by Mallakastrioti
Teme interesante Zeus.

Por personalisht jam pjeserisht dakort me çka sjell. Autoktonia jone nuk mund te vihet ne dyshim per disa arsye.

E para ka te beje me epoken paragreke apo edhe parailire (siç dime si iliret dhe greket shfaqen gati ne te njejten periudhe ne historigrafi, ne mund te kundershtojme qe nuk ka saktesi ne tekstet e keshtuquajtura te lashta kur flitet per keto popullsi dominante ne Ballkan, por nuk mund te injorojme teresisht autoret e lashte).
Epoka paragreke dhe parailire apo ndryshe e quajtur periudha pellazgjike (ketu sigurisht mund te diskutohet deri ne pafundesi cila ka qene kjo popullsi), nuk besoj se ka te beje me rracat semite, perkundrazi. Ne se Doret e lashte ishin pellazge, te cilet shkuan dhe mesyne Peleponezin, pra keta Dore-pellazge gjeten nje popullsi tjeter aty, ate Jone e cila edhe kjo shume here na del popullsi pellazge. Pyetja lind çishin pellazget dhe muret pellazgjike apo ciklopike. U ndertuan prej semiteve? Nuk besoj, pasi popullsite semite mund te identifikohen me teper me popullsi nomade, apo endacake. Nuk kemi te dhena qe popullsite semite te adhuronin gurin (PIETRA=PER TRA), te kene qene te lidhur me token apo TRUallin, te kene qene popullsi luftarake, te kene qene popullsi e cila mund te nenshtronte popullsi te tjera, pasi i nje niveli apo kulture me te lashte dhe me te perparuar.
Nuk kemi te dhena per emigrime prej Perendimit drejt Lindjes (popullsi te tera te zhvilluara, qe shkojne dhe neneshtrojne popullsi te tjera te prapambetura). Nje shoqeri e prapambetur asimilohet apo neneshtrohet prej nje popullsie me te zhvilluar. Te keshtuquajtur ilir ishin te paret qe hyne ne epoken e hekurit dhe duam apo jo ne nje popullsi qe per here te pare posedon apo ka ne dore nje element te tille metalor nuk e perdor vetem per shpata dhe arme, por edhe per paremenda dhe per punimin apo plugimin e tokes (quhet revolucion ky).
Popullsite kelte ndoshta jane ato qe erdhen ne Ballkan dhe u asimiluan prej vendasve. Sigurisht qe sollen edhe njohurite apo nje pjese te kultures se tyre, por u asimiluan prej vendasve.
Doret zbriten ne Peleponez, por Doret nuk neneshtruan Jonet, por krijuan nje hibridizem me Jonet. U krijua nje rrace ere hibride qe u quajten Hellene. Prej nga erdhen keta Dore ? Cila pjese veriore, pasi thuhet qe zbriten prej veriut? Nje perzierje Thrakase-Ilire? Iliret nje perzierje Pellazgo-Kelte? Thraket nje perzierje Pellazgo-Ilire?
Albanet apo ALPINET mos ndoshta ishin popullsite qe u asimiluan prej vendasve dhe jo keto qe neneshtruan vendasit? Nuk mendoj se Spanja, Franca, Italia apo edhe Anglia (ku shfaqen Albanet) ishin me te perparuar se Pellazget-shqiptar te moçem.

Re: Origjina e shqiptareve.

Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2012 8:12 pm
by Zeus10
Problemi me pellazget, iliret bile dhe helenet eshte qe nuk kemi absolutisht fare fakte qe te kene egzistuar, pale te krijojme nje lidhje historike me ta te qendrueshme dhe te provueshme. Ata "egzistojne" vetem ne disa libra mesjetare, qe nuk e dime vertete kujt i referohen ne kohe dhe hapesire, ne nje forme mitologjike dhe per mendimin tim aspak te besueshme. Muret ciklopike, duke u gjendur ne gjithe Mesdheun duke filluar qe nga Portugalia deri ne Lindjen e Mesme, tregojne perkundrazi egzaktesisht shtrirjen e nje kulture te caktuar, qe une i emerova albane, sepse keshtu quhen vendet me te spikatura qe ata kane jetuar.
Some tribes from Latium have the names Albani, Albenses, Bolani, Abolani (Pliny, lib.III.9.16). The ancient authors often understood the entire Latin people under the terms Albani and Albanenses. Virgil calls all the cities of Latium urbes Albanae (Aen. VII. 601-2).
In the oldest inscriptions of Latium we often find the family name Albus and Albius (C. I. L. vol. I. nr. 122. 129. 468. 830; Tacitus, Ann. VI. c. 34; Strabo, lib. XI. 4. 4; Isidorus, Orig. XIX. 23. 7). Alba was an ancient king of Latium, son of king Latinus Silvius (Livy, lib. I. 3; Dionys. Hal. I. 71).
Finally, we note here that the national religion of the Latinii of Italy was called lex Albana (C. I. L. vol. I. nr. 807), certainly in antithesis with lex Romana and with mos Romanus


THE HISTORIE OF NATVRE,
WRITTEN BY C. PLINIVS
SECVNDVS.


Of old Latins, the Cascantenses, Erganicenses, Gracchuritanes, leonicenses, Ossigerdenses. Of confederates within the league, the Tarragenses. Tributaries besides, the Arcobricenses, Andologenses, Arocelitanes, Bursaonenses, Calaguritanes surnamed Fibularenses, complutenses, Carenses, Cincenses, Cortonenses, Dammanitanes, latrenses, Iturisenses, Ispalenses, Ilumberitanes, Lacetanes, Vibienses, Pompelonenses and Segienses. There resort to Carthage for law 62 severall States, besides the Islanders. Out of the Colonie Accitana, the Gemellenses, also Libisosona surnamed Foroaugustana: which two are endued with the franchises of Italie: out of the Colonie Salariensis, the Oppidanes of old Latium, Castulonenses, whom Cæsar calleth Venales. The Setabitanes, who are also Augustanes, and the Valerrienses. But of the Tributaries, of greatest name bee the Babanenses, the Bascianes, the Consaburenses, Dianenses, Egelestanes, Ilorcitani, Laminitani, Mentesani, the same that Oritani; and the Mentesani who otherwise are Bastuli: Oretanes who also are called Germani, the cheefe of the Celtiberians, the Segobrigenses, and the Toletanes of Carpetania, dwelling upon the river Tagus. Next to them the Viacienses and Virgilienses. To the assises or law court Cluniensis, the Varduli bring fourteene nations; of which I list to name none but the Albanenses.

Of the Ligurians, the most renowmed beyond the Alpes, are the Sallij, Deceates, and Oxubij: on this side, the Veneni, and descended from the Caturiges, the Vagienni, Statyelli, Vibelli, Magelli, Euburiates, Casmonates, Veliates, and those, whose townes wee will declare in the next coast. The river Rutuba, the towne Albium Intemelium, the river Merula, the towne Albium Ingaunum, the port or haven towne Vadum Sabatium, the river Porcifera, the towne Genua, the river Feritor, the Port Delphini, Tigulia: within, Segesta Tiguloiorum: the river Macra which limiteth Liguria. Now on the backe side behind all these townes abovenamed, is Apenine, the highest mountain of all Italie, reaching from the Alpes with a continuall ridge of hils, to the streights of Sicilie. From the other side thereof to Padus, the richest river of all Italie, all the countrey shineth with goodly faire townes, to with, Liberna, Dertona a colonie, Iria, Barderates, industria, Pollentia, Carrea, which also is named Polentia, Foro Fulvij the same that Valentinum, Augusta of the Vagienni: Alba Pompeia, Asta, and Aquæ Statyellorum. And this is the ninth Canton, after the Geographie of Augustus. This coast or tract of Liguria containeth between the rivers Varus and Macra 211 miles. To it is adjoined the seventh, wherein is Hetruria from the river Macra: and it ofentimes chaunged the name. In old time the Pelasgians chased the Umbrians from thence: and by them the Lydians did the like, of whose king, named they were Tyrhheni: but soone after, of their ceremonies in sacrificing, in the Greekes language Thusci

Re: Origjina e shqiptareve.

Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2012 8:39 pm
by Mallakastrioti
Mendimi im eshte se Plini ka kopjuar autoret e tjere me perpara tij. Historia zyrtare nis me Herokdotin, duam apo jo ne kjo eshte e verteta. Ka ekzistuar apo jo Herokdoti ne kete nuk e dime. Ka ekzistuar apo jo vepra e tij ku edhe Plini eshte mbeshtetur ne kete nuk e dime. Fakt eshte se muret Ciklopike apo Pellazgjike gjenden ende sot ne gjithe vendet apo zonat qe je duke permendur, Zeus. Homeri flet per Pellazge, Tuqiditi flet e shkruan per pellazge, Heroktodi i permend, Plini u mbeshtet diku qe permend keto popullsi.

Qe kane qene popullsi e lidhur me token, kete na e verteton adhurimi qe kane patur per gurin (elementi baze per gjithe gjetjet se periudhes paraklasike se keshtuquajtur greke).

Ilire, helene, maqedonas, epirote, trak, panone...etj...etj...jane thjesht fise prej se njejtes rrenje. Ishin Pellazge? Ndoshta...ndoshta mund ti quajme pellazge apo ndoshta kane patur nje emertim tjeter qe ne nuk dime, por qendron fakti qe permendet nje popullsi paragreke dhe parailire me mertimin "pellazge"
Neoliti eshte nje deshmi ne Ballkan. Nuk mund te jete nje shoqeri semite, pasi semitet jane njohur si popullsi endacake dhe jo e qendrueshme. Nuk mund te injorojme Kulturen e Kurbinit, Vinçes dhe Maliqit.

Re: Origjina e shqiptareve.

Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2012 9:46 pm
by Zeus10
Herodoti per mendimin tim dhe shume te tjereve, megjithese eshte kuotuar si :"Babai i Historise", ngelet "i dyshuari i madh" i historise. Menduar qe ka jetuar ne shekullin e 5-te para Krishtit, me kopjen me te vjeter te vepres se tij, te "shkruajtur" vetem ne shekullin e 10 -Pas Krishtit, kopje e humbur. Ka me pas vetem 7 kopje te vepres se tij, me e "heshmja" i perket shekullit te 14 Pas Krishtit, "te humbura" keto, per disa qindra vjete te tjere, deri ne periudhen e "Rilindjes Evropiane"-periudhe kur gjermanet, "zbuluan" Helladen dhe "provuan" qe greket e vjeter, ishin vecse evropiano-veriore, me tipare fiziologjike si ato te gjermaneve te sotem.
Pervec ketyre qe thame, vepra e Herodotit, eshte e shkruar me nje stil shume te dyshimte, shume te ngjashem me kohen e nacionalizmave dhe fare te panatyrshem per kohen qe duhet ti perkiste. Mbushur me kontradikta dhe komplet e paqarte, ajo perfaqson per mendimin tim, ate cka nuk duhet marre per baze, kur gjurmon historine.

Re: Origjina e shqiptareve.

Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2012 9:49 pm
by Mallakastrioti
Perse duhet marre per baze Plini? Edhe ai shfaqet ne mesjete.....(vepra e tij sillet prej "nipit" te tij???)

Re: Origjina e shqiptareve.

Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2012 9:56 pm
by Mallakastrioti
Perse duhen marre per baze Skilaksi i Karaindise (Pseudo Skilaks)...Stefan Bizanti (edhe Bizanti vihet ne dyshim qe ka ekzistuar), Likofroni i Eubese (te cilit i kundershtohen sot çfare ka shkruar)....

Re: Origjina e shqiptareve.

Posted: Fri Mar 16, 2012 10:07 pm
by Zeus10
Pikerisht Mallakastrioti, asnje nuk duhet marre per baze, besueshmeria e tyre eshte afer zeros.

Re: Origjina e shqiptareve.

Posted: Sat Mar 17, 2012 5:00 pm
by erix77
per zeusin historia e njerezimit fillon vetem 1000 vjet me pare ndersa tani Shqiptaret na vijne nga portugalia,specialiteti i zeusit po behen teorite konspiracioniste...............jemi ne pritje te cudise te radhes!

Re: Origjina e shqiptareve.

Posted: Sat Mar 17, 2012 6:31 pm
by Zeus10
erix77 wrote:per zeusin historia e njerezimit fillon vetem 1000 vjet me pare ndersa tani Shqiptaret na vijne nga portugalia,specialiteti i zeusit po behen teorite konspiracioniste...............jemi ne pritje te cudise te radhes!
Po erix, megjithese une jam i sigurte qe historia e njerezimit fillon shume perpara 1100 vjetesh, une kam bindjen e plote, qe ato qe ne na paraqiten si tekste te lashta, ne te cilat eshte bazuar gjithe shkrimi i historise, nuk e kalojne 1100 vjetet. Persa i perket konspiracionit, ate nuk e pelqej une, por une jam mese i bindur, qe eshte bere nje konspiracion i madh ne historine e Europes dhe ajo qe na paraqitet eshte krejt e ndryshme nga ajo qe ka ndodhur vertete, sidomos ne raportin gjuhe-popuj, i cili na paraqitet si nje konstante e pandryshueshme qe nga lashtesia, por qe nuk eshte fare i vertete.

Re: Origjina e shqiptareve.

Posted: Mon Mar 19, 2012 6:05 pm
by ALBPelasgian
Zeus10 wrote:Le te diskutojme per origjinen e popullit shqiptar. A jemi te mocem ne kete vend? A jemi te perjetshem aty, ne kuptimin relativ te fjales? A mos jemi nje shtresim mbi autoktonet? A kemi larguar dike prej andej? Apo jemi po aq te vjeter, sa gjithe kombet rreth nesh?
Opinioni im:
Ne jemi popullsite e ardhura nga PERENDIMI, ndoshta avangarda e atyre qe ne histori njihen si romake. Kjo avangarde perfshin popullsite qe dikur banonin rreth sot Portugalise, Spanjes edhe Frances qe njihen ne histori me emrin Albane dhe e vendosen qendren e tyre, atje ku sot eshte Roma. Albanet qe u vendosen ne Shqiperi zhvendosen ose treten popullsine vendase, qe ka qene semitike, ose dhe me e larget, duke u bere kombi dominant ne keto troje, per te pakten 1000 vjete. Gjuha e folur nga keta Albane u zevendesua ne Perendim nga gjuhet Romance te Perendimit, kurse ne Lindje nga gjuha Romake e Lindjes(greqishtja) dhe gjuhet e Ortodoksise Sllavike. Gjuha vernakulare e albaneve, ka filluar ne Portugali dhe ka mbaruar ne Lindjen e Mesme.
Perendimi i Ballkanit, gjeografia e te cilit ka bere te mundur ruajtjen madje edhe konservative te popullit dinarik qe jetonte aty nuk njeh ndonje mbishtresim te ardhur nga Perendimi. Rrenja -alb e perhapur ne gjeografine evropiane s'deshmon per kurrfare ardhjeje. S'ka as edhe nje grimce prove qe te deshmoje per nje vendosje albanesh ne Shqiperi apo ne pjesen perendimore te Ballkanit:

*In the 2nd century BC, the History of the World written by Polybius, mentions a location named Arbon[15] or Arbo[16] (Greek: Άρβωνα)[17] that was perhaps an island[18] in Liburnia or another location within Illyria. Stephanus of Byzantium centuries later, cites Polybius, saying it was a city in Illyria and gives an ethnic name (see below) for its inhabitants. Most likely it is a Croatian island of Rab.

*In the 2nd century AD, Ptolemy, the geographer and astronomer from Alexandria, drafted a map that shows the city of Albanopolis (located Northeast of Durrës). Ptolemy also mentions the Illyrian tribe named Albanoi,[19] who lived around this city.

*In the 6th century AD, Stephanus of Byzantium in his important geographical dictionary entitled Ethnica (Εθνικά)[20] mentions a city in Illyria called Arbon (Greek: Αρβών), with its inhabitants called Arbonios (Greek: Αρβώνιος) and Arbonites (Greek: Αρβωνίτης). He cites Polybius[20] (he does so many[21][22] times in ethnica) and does not claim that such city or people existed during his time.
Per Albanet e Perendimit, besoj, qe keni marre nje pershtypje te gabuar duke nderruar kahjen historike te levizjeve nga lindje-perendim (sic ishte realisht) ne perendim-lindje. Sic dihet pas luftes se pare te Trojes, nje popullsi e konsiderueshme dardane u shprengul ne drejtim te perendimit (subjekt qe me pas u trajtua edhe ne Odise), ne Itali e madje edhe me larg. Trajektorja e nje levizjeje te tille duhet te kete qene perafersisht kesisoj:

Image

Nje dimension tjeter qe s'duhet te anashkalohet eshte edhe fakti qe 'albanet' trazonin origjinen e tyre tek trojanet, ashtu sic deshmon citati ne vazhdim:
Titus Livius or Livy [Chapters 11-20]

Preparations were made on both sides with the utmost vigour for a warvery like a civil one, in a manner between parents and children, both being of Trojan stock: for from Troy came Lavinium, from Lavinium, Alba, and the Romans were descended from the stock of the Alban kings.
Titus Livius or Livy [Chapters 22-25]

"Hear, O Jupiter; hear, O pater patratus of the Alban people, and ye...
Virgil, Aen. VII.v.219-220

..and Jupiter Latiaris, worshipped on the mountain Alban, did not represent the god of the third generation, the Hellenic Jove of the theomachy, who had usurped the throne of Saturn, but the great God of the Pelasgian nation, the divinity of light and atmospheric phenomena, to whom Saturn was assimilated, the historic representative of the tilling of the earth, of prosperity and abundance.
The most famous cult of the great Pelasgian God, as known by history to this day, was at Dodona in the Epirus...
Image
The Aneid gives us an alternative, and possibly complementary meaning of the name Alban. The Trojans used to call themselves Albans while they were in Latium, giving the impression that their name had something in common with the giant called Albion who was killed by Hercules. It seems that Alban (Albion) must be a very ancient name.
He has the Alban name of Silvius, and he is your son, to be born after your passing; your queen Lavinia will rear him in the forests, and he will be a king and sire of kings, and founder of our dynasty which shall rule from Alba Longa. The nearest to him, there, is Procas, the pride of the Trojan race; and next Capys and Numitor, and Aeneas Silvius, who will revive your own name and be a prince exalted alike in his righteousness and his arms, if in fact he shall ever succeed to the Alban throne.
Madje edhe vete romaket besonin qe Herakliu kishte ardhur ne Itali nga ana tjeter e detit:
The Roman name for the Greek hero Heracles. The worship of Hercules at Rome and in Italy requires a separate consideration. His worship there is connected by late, especially Roman writers, with the hero's expedition to fetch the oxen of Geryones; and the principal points are, that Hercules in the West abolished human sacrifices among the Sabines, established the worship of fire, and slew Cacus, a robber, who had stolen eight of his oxen. (Dionys. i. 14; CACUS.) The aborigines, and especially Evander, honoured the hero with divine worship. (Serv. ad Aen. viii. 51, 269.) Hercules, in return, feasted the people, and presented the king with lands, requesting that sacrifices should be offered to him every year, according to Greek rites. Two distinguished families, the Potitii and Pinarii, were instructed in these Greek rites, and appointed hereditary managers of the festival. But Hercules made a distinction between these two families, which continued to exist for a long time after; for, as Pinarius arrived too late at the repast, the god punished him by declaring that lie and his descendants should be excluded for ever from the sacrificial feast. Thus the custom arose for the Pinarii to act the part of servants at the feast. (Diod. iv. 21; Dionys. i. 39, &c.; Liv. i. 40, v. 34; Nepos, Hann. 3; Plut. Quaest. Rom. 18; Ov. Fast. i. 581.) The Fabia gens traced its origin to Hercules, and Fauna and Acca Laurentia are called mistresses of Hercules. In this manner the Romans connected their earliest legends with Hercules. (Macrob. Sat. i. 10; August. de Civ. Dei, vi. 7.) It should be observed that in the Italian traditions the hero bore the name of Recaranus, and this Recaranus was afterwards identified with the Greek Heracles. He had two temples at Rome, one was a small round temple of Hercules Victor, or Hercules Triumphalis, between the river and the Circus Maximus, in the forum boarium, and contained a statue, which was dressed in the triumphal robes whenever a general celebrated a triumph. In front of this statue was the ara maxima, on which, after a triumph, the tenth of the booty was deposited for distribution among the citizens. (Liv. x. 23; Plin . H. N. xxxiv. 7, 16 ; Macrob. Sat. iii. 6; Tacit. Ann. xii. 24; Serv. ad Aen. xii. 24; Athen. v. 65; comp. Dionys. i. 40.) The second temple stood near the porta Trigemina, and contained a bronze statue and the altar on which Hercules himself was believed to have once offered a sacrifice. (Dionys. i. 39, 40; Plut. Quaest. Rom. 60; Plin. H. N. xxxiii. 12, 45.) Here the city praetor offered every year a young cow, which was consumed by the people within the sanctuary. The Roman Hercules was regarded as the giver of health (Lydus, de Mens. p. 92), and his priests were called by a Sabine name Cupenci. (Serv. ad Aen. xii. 539.) At Rome he was further connected with the Muses, whence he is called Musagetes, and was represented with a lyre, of which there is no trace in Greece. The identity of the Italian with the Greek Heracles is attested not only by the resemblance in the traditions and the mode of worship, but by the distinct belief of the Romans themselves. The Greek colonies had introduced his worship into Italy, and it was thence carried to Rome, into Gaul, Spain, arid even Germany. (Tac. Germ. 2.) But it is, nevertheless, in the highest degree probable that the Greek mythus was engrafted upon, or supplied the place of that about the Italian Recaranus or Garanus. [GARANUS.]
...nje konfuziteti kaq qesharak nuk i kishte shpetuar as Marin Barleti yne i madh, kur thoshte qe arberit heqin origjinen e tyre nga albanet e Italise. Disa rreshta me poshte ai e pergenjeshtron veteveten kur thote qe arberit jane te njejte me epirotet dhe maqedonet e vjeter. Filli i ketij gabimi trashanik duhet te kerkohet tek autoret bizantin, si Ataliati:
Laonikos Chalkokondyles (c. 1423–1490), the Byzantine historian, thought that the Albanians hailed from Italy. The theory has its origin in the first mention of Albanians, made by Attaliates (11th century): "... For when subsequent commanders made base and shameful plans and decisions, not only was the island lost to Byzantium, but also the greater part of the army. Unfortunately, the people who had once been our allies and who possessed the same rights as citizens and the same religion, i.e. the Albanians and the Latins, who live in the Italian regions of our Empire beyond Western Rome, quite suddenly became enemies when Michael Dokenianos insanely directed his command against their leaders..."[98]
Kjo hipoteze (besoj qe i jap teper besueshmeri po ta quaj te tille..po nejse) harron ne menyre cinike faktin e mirenjohur qe perandoret bizantin shprengulen nje pjese te ndjeshme te popullsise arberore ne jug te Italise, te cilen donin t'ia bashkengjisnin Bizantit.

Rrjedhimisht, per t'i vene kapakun gjithe asaj qe u tha me larte ishte Italia ajo qe u ushqye vazhdimisht prej Ballkanit dhe jo e kunderta. Eshte e mireargumentuar levizja danubiane ne drejtim te Italise se veriut ashti si dhe ajo e Ballkanit perendimor (mesapet, dardanet e fise te tjera ne Greqine perendimore), qe nga shek. XIII p.l.K. Kunder nje origjine te supozuar nga Evropa perendimore flasin konkordancat e pakta midis shqipes dhe keltishtes. Lidhjet e nduarnduarshme te shqipes me susbtratin e vjeter pre-helenik ashtu edhe me ate helenik e bejne objektivisht te pamundshem cfaredo lidhjeje me Evropen perendimore.

Se fundmi, une nuk mendoj se nje dyshim i skajshem i gjithe literatures greko-romake eshte i perligjur. Une kam prirje t'i besoj autenticitetit te tyre per aq kohe sa ato jane te mbeshtetura ne menyre solide nga arkeologjia dhe diciplina te tjera shkencore. S'perjashtohet qe nje pjese e vogel e teksteve te kene pesuar zvetnime, si pasoje e kalimit te tekstit nga dora ne dore. Nje pjese tjeter qe i shpetoi asgjesimit te totalitarizmit te ideologjise kristiane u perpunuan ne filtrat e kishes katolike gjate mesjetes. Por, ne teresi tekstet e lashta greko-romake mbeten autentike.

Re: Origjina e shqiptareve.

Posted: Mon Mar 19, 2012 6:54 pm
by Zeus10
Alb, jam dakord me arsyetimin nese do te perdorim ato quota, qe jane perdorur prej teje ne postim dhe dikur prej meje per te mbeshtetur ate kendveshtrim. Por, e para, kendveshtrimi im nuk synon nje veshtrim dinamik te origjines me te hershme te tyre, por nje kendveshtrim statik per nje moment te provueshem te historise, duke mos perjashtuar levizjet e panumerta, qe dhe sot e kesaj dite e shoqerojne racen tone, me ndryshimin e vetem qe sot ka kufij etnike dhe politike dhe e dyta, nuk mund te flitet per kristalizime te pastra popujsh, sa me larg te shkosh ne histori dhe kjo eshte e vlefshme dhe per popullin shqiptar. Gjithashtu, une ju garantoj te gjitheve juve, qe u shqetesuat me te drejte, per hipotezen time rreth albaneve te Perendimit, se nese kjo hipoteze do te ishte e vertete, atehere asnje impakt negativ nuk do te kete kjo kundrejt historise tone, perkundrazi, kjo do i bente paraardhesit tane sundimtaret edhe te pjeses perendimore te Kontinentit Plake, qekurse, une kam bindjen se shtepia akoma me e vjeter e tyre, ka filluar diku ne Lindjen e Mesme dhe ka perfunduar ne Ballkan.
Se fundmi, une nuk mendoj se nje dyshim i skajshem i gjithe literatures greko-romake eshte i perligjur. Une kam prirje t'i besoj autenticitetit te tyre per aq kohe sa ato jane te mbeshtetura ne menyre solide nga arkeologjia dhe diciplina te tjera shkencore.
Pikerisht ky eshte problemi, se jo vetem qe ato vuajne autenticitetin e tyre dhe jane totalisht te shkruajtura shume kohe pas ndodhive qe ato pershkruajne, por edhe nuk mbeshteten aspak nga arkeologjia, pa permendur qe kjo e fundit vuan nga handikape te medha, ne percaktimin e moshes se artifakteve dhe metodes krahasimtare.

Re: Origjina e shqiptareve.

Posted: Mon Mar 19, 2012 10:20 pm
by ALBPelasgian
Prapseprape, cfaredo lidhje me ta mbetet problematike: pavaresisht origjines se tyre te dokumentuar ballkano-anatoliane, albanet e Evropes (ne kohen klasike por edhe me vone) kishin nje identitet te paqarte. Dua te them se ne nuk dime ne c'shkalle u latinizuan apo ne c'shkalle ruajten identitetin e tyre te mocem. Ja po e shkepus nje pjese te Prokopit:
Procopius-The Gothic War, Book V, 80: For among the Bruttii are the Epizephyrian Locrians and the inhabitants of Croton and Thurii. But north of the gulf the first inhabitants are Greeks, called Epirotes, as far as the city of Epidamnus, which is situated on the sea. And adjoining this is the land of Precalis, beyond which is the territory called Dalmatia, all of which is counted as part of the western empire. And beyond that point is Liburnia,[81] and Istria, and the land of the Veneti extending to the city of Ravenna. These countries are situated on the sea in that region. But above them are the Siscii and Suevi (not those who are subjects of the Franks, but another group), who inhabit the interior. And beyond these are settled the Carnii and Norici. On the right of these dwell the Dacians and Pannonians, who hold a number of towns, including Singidunum[82] and Sirmium, and extend as far as the Ister River. Now these peoples north of the Ionian Gulf were ruled by the Goths at the beginning of this war, but beyond the city of Ravenna on the left of the river Po the country was inhabited by the Ligurians.[83] And to the north of them live the Albani in an exceedingly good land called Langovilla, and beyond these are the nations subject to the Franks, while the country to the west is held by the Gauls and after them the Spaniards. On the right of the Po are Aemilia[84] and the Tuscan peoples, which extend as far as the boundaries of Rome. So much, then, for this.”